Last week we finished counting all the votes for the Games of the Year and announced the winners.  This week the arguing part begins. Just kidding, well, sort of. Not to take anything away from our new sister show, Argue the Toss, but the Games of the Year contest always ends up having a little bit of controversy. Otherwise, it wouldn’t be as fun!

As with previous years, we let the GiN Readers choose their champions, and 100,000 of you were up for that challenge. So, did the best games actually win? Our editors weigh in on the Games of the Year winners this week.